Good Food Pittsburgh


  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Pinterest
  • Twitter
  • YouTube

Pittsburgh’s Daily Food News Site.

  • News
  • Guides
  • Events
  • New Openings
  • About Us
  • Contact
  • Privacy

Our Favorite Pies in Pittsburgh

March 14, 2019 by Madeline Quigley Leave a Comment

Photo: Sand Hill Berries

It’s that time of year again… pi day! Happy 3.14, yinz!

To help you pay your respect to this culinary delight, we have rounded up a few of our favorite pies in Pittsburgh. From chocolate to berry, there is something on this list for everyone.

What is your favorite pie in Pittsburgh? Please leave it in the comments below!

Have a great pie picture? We want to see! Please tag @goodfoodpgh and #goodfoodpgh.

The best pies in Pittsburgh:

Coconut Cream Pie from Grant Bar

View this post on Instagram

It's official… Grant Bar has the best pies in Pittsburgh! #roadfood #coconutcreampie #roadfoodpennsylvania #grantbar #pie #pienation #millvale #pieapalooza

A post shared by Cliff Strutz (@jcstrutz) on Jun 6, 2016 at 4:25pm PDT

This famous pie is made fresh daily and features a mountain of whipped cream topped with crunchy coconut flakes. Pie lovers from all over Pittsburgh head to Millvale to grab a slice of this pie, so be sure to stop by early, as it sells out almost every single day!

Grant Bar (114 Grant Avenue)

Key Lime Pie from Jean-Marc Chatellier’s

Photo: Jean-Marc Chatellier’s French Bakery

Another delicious Millvale pie is the Key Lime pie at Jean-Marc French bakery. While all of Jean-Marc’s pies are delicious, their “authentic” key lime is tart, creamy, and spectacular.

Jean-Marc Chatellier’s French Bakery (213 North Avenue)

Slab Pies from Pie Bird

View this post on Instagram

Back at it this weekend. Find us at @springhillbrewing tomorrow night! #pielife #152xx #412

A post shared by Piebird (@piebirdpgh) on Mar 1, 2019 at 3:56pm PST

With Pie Bird’s slab pies, the delicious and gooey flavors of pie are combined with the convenience of sheet cake. Pittsburgh’s boutique pie distributor, Pie Bird, can be found serving their slab pies at popups and events around the city. A few popular slab pie flavors include:

Pie Bird also runs a “Pie Club” where subscribers get a fresh and seasonal pie every month. The Spring 2019 Pie Club begins in April and features Coconut Cream, Strawberry Rhubarb, and German Chocolate pies. Know someone with a birthday coming up? A pie subscription is a great gift!

More information can be found online.

Pie Bird (5304 Butler Street)

Vinegar and Chocolate Chess Pies from Pie for Breakfast

View this post on Instagram

This pie tastes like a half-baked brownie, so obviously I ate it at 930am. @pieforbreakfastpgh is an order, not a suggestion

A post shared by Madeline Quigley (@burghgal) on Mar 3, 2019 at 3:38pm PST

It was already hard enough to narrow it down to two, so we could never pick just one pie at Pittsburgh’s namesake pie restaurant, Pie for Breakfast. As the name would suggest, this all-day European diner offers a variety of fresh, homemade pies in addition to their funky breakfast menu. The vinegar pie has already made a name for itself in Pittsburgh, with the restaurant describing it as a “pecan pie without the pecans.” The Chocolate Chess is another favorite pie, mimicking the texture and flavor of a half-baked brownie. Be sure to stop by and check it out for yourself!

Pie for Breakfast (200 N. Craig Street)

Berry Pies from Sand Hill Berries

Photo: Sand Hill Berries

Located just south of the city, Sand Hill Berries is known for their homemade jams, charming atmosphere, and absolutely colossal pies. Stop by the farm to pick up one of these famous, double-crusted pies, made with locally grown fruit. Popular flavors include: raspberry, blackberry, blueberry, and more!

Starting in late spring, customers can enjoy a slice la mode on the farm’s beautiful patio at The Cabin Café.

Sand Hill Berries (304 Deerfield Road)

Oreo Creme Pie at Eat’n Park

Photo: Eat’n Park

No meal at Eat’n Park is complete without a slice of one of the restaurant’s popular pies. In honor of pi day, the restaurant is sharing a pie chart of their most popular pies. Oreo Creme Pie comes in on top – and we concur! It’s delicious!

Guests can grab a pie on the fly by ordering online, through Eat’n Park’s mobile app, or through Eat’n Park’s pickup window. 

Eat’n Park (Multiple Locations)

What is your favorite pie in Pittsburgh? Please leave it in the comments below!

Filed Under: Featured, News

Follow us on Facebook and Instagram for daily updates!

Enter your email below to get weekly updates delivered straight to your inbox!

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Pinterest
  • Twitter

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Most Popular

Gussy’s Bagels in Oakland Is Adding Pizza By the Slice

All The Best Drive-Thru Christmas Lights Near Pittsburgh

17 New Restaurants in Pittsburgh to Try This Fall

7 Drivable Weekend Road Trips to Take This Fall

Fall Festivals Near Me: Pittsburgh Fall Festivals 2022

  • Email
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Twitter

Pittsburgh’s Daily Food News Website

Site Map

  • News
  • Guides
  • Events
  • New Openings
  • About Us
  • Contact
  • Privacy

Advertising

Interested in advertising on Good Food Pittsburgh?

Learn More

Email Newsletter

Sign up to receive email updates and news from GoodFoodPittsburgh.

Archives

© 2023 GoodFoodPittsburgh · All Rights Reserved