This Thanksgiving, give thanks to these amazing Pittsburgh bakers who are still taking orders for holiday pies, cakes and cookies!
Farmer x Baker
Get your orders in by November 20 for Thanksgiving treats like Bourbon Pecan Pie, Classic Apple Pie, Pumpkin Tart, Salted Maple Pie, Sweet Potato Pie with Chocolate Crust & Meringue (!!!), and Vegan Carrot Cake. They also have brunch boxes, with bagels, cream cheese, and more. Order here.
The Pie Place
This South Hills shop is the place for pies in Pittsburgh. They’re taking orders now (November 18 is the last day!) for Thanksgiving week, with pickup times on Monday, Tuesday and Wednesday. Options include Pumpkin, Pumpkin Cream, Chocolate Cream, Dutch Apple, Cherry, Key Lime and about a dozen more – plus Cinnamon Rolls, Cheesecakes, and tarts. They also have ‘take and bake’ options, for that fresh-baked taste. Order here.
Dave’s Terrace Bakery
One of Pittsburgh best-loved hidden gems is currently taking orders for Thanksgiving pies (pumpkin, fruit, whipped cream or meringue), along with rolls, bread, cakes, pumpkin rolls and Thanksgiving cookies. Call 412-655-9233 to order.
Get farm-fresh pies from Simmons Farm in McMurray. Call 724-941-1490 to order.
Allegro Hearth Bakery
Plant-based bakery Allegro Hearth Bakery has just unveiled a new pie, just in time for the holiday, with a new, more ‘traditional’ flaky crust. Pumpkin pies are $18 and apple pies are $20, and both are currently available for pre-order (pickup on Tuesday and Wednesday next week) on their website.
The last day to order desserts in time for Thanksgiving from Oakmont Bakery is Sunday, November 21. Thanksgiving specials include Pumpkin Pie, Pumpkin Cheesecake, pumpkin rolls, and Thanksgiving cupcakes (featuring “Stuffing, Mashed Potatoes & Gravy, Corn, Turkey, Green Beans & Pumpkin Pie”). Order online or call 412-826-1606.
Gluten Free Goat
Get your gluten-free sweet treats at Gluten Free Goat. This year, they’re offering Thanksgiving pies, including Pumpkin and Apple, plus take-and-bake cinnamon rolls, apple cider doughnuts, pumpkin Pop Tarts, and stuffing mix. Order online.
The last day to order Thanksgiving desserts from Signature Desserts is November 20. In addition to classic pies and tarts (including Pumpkin, Egg Custard, Pecan, Apple and Triple Berry), they also have Thanksgiving cupcakes, pumpkin rolls, Strudel, Pumpkin Cheesecake, German Chocolate Cake, and their super-popular (and best-selling!) Caramel Apple Walnut Cake.
Try something different for dessert this year, and order a Thanksgiving Turkey Ice Cream Cake from Sarris Candies in Canonsburg. It’s made with chocolate and vanilla ice cream, and covered in chocolate whipped icing. Order online.
Confections by Casey Renee
Order by Friday, November 19 to get one some delicious desserts on your Thanksgiving table by James Beard Award-nominated pastry chef Casey Renee. Her Thanksgiving pies includes Brûléed Pumpkin, Apple Cranberry, Dutch Triple Berry and Chocolate Pecan, along with Pumpkin Whoopie Pies, and she also has a ‘Sweet Sampler’ available, with an assortment of truffles and mini pies. Order online.